Guides

Daycare vs. Nanny vs. Staying Home: How to Decide (With Real Costs)

Home daycare is usually cheapest, a nanny costs the most, and staying home depends on the paycheck you'd give up. How to compare them, nanny taxes included.

By the DadMoneyPlan team · Published · Last reviewed

For one baby, home daycare is usually the cheapest paid option, a daycare center is next, and a full-time nanny costs the most. Staying home has no bill, but it costs the paycheck you give up, plus the retirement savings and raises that go with it. The right answer depends on your local prices and how much the lower-earning parent takes home.

Want to see your own numbers side by side? Use our childcare cost calculator. It includes nanny taxes and the tax breaks for each option.

The options at a glance

Option Typical cost (one infant) Best for
Daycare center about $1,000 to $2,000+ a month Reliable hours, licensed staff, backup coverage
Home daycare often less than a center Smaller groups, homier feel, lower price
Nanny about $3,500 to $4,500 a month full time Flexibility, one-on-one care, two or more kids
Family free to a “thank you” payment Trust and savings, if family is willing and close
One parent home the after-tax pay you give up When childcare would eat most of one paycheck

Prices swing a lot by state. Child Care Aware of America found infant center care costs about $6,500 a year in the cheapest state and over $27,000 in the most expensive. Call a few places near you for real quotes, and get on waitlists early. Infant spots fill up fast.

Daycare center

Pros: licensed and inspected, set hours, staff coverage when a teacher is sick, and a built-in social life for your kid.

Cons: you’ll need a backup plan when your baby is sick (and in year one, they’ll be sick a lot), strict pickup times, and waitlists.

Home daycare (family child care)

A provider cares for a small group of kids in their own home. It’s often cheaper than a center and can feel more personal.

Pros: smaller groups, often more flexible, usually lower cost.

Cons: if the provider is sick or on vacation, you have no care. Check that they’re licensed in your state, and ask about their backup plan.

A nanny

Care.com’s 2026 cost report found parents post nanny rates averaging about $21.75 an hour for one child, and more in big cities. Full time, that’s around $3,800 a month before taxes.

Pros: care at your house, on your schedule, and one-on-one attention. With two or more kids, a nanny can cost about the same as two daycare spots. A nanny share with another family can cut the cost.

Cons: the highest price, and you become an employer.

Don’t forget nanny taxes

If you pay a nanny $3,000 or more in 2026, you’re a household employer under IRS rules. That means:

  • Social Security and Medicare: you withhold 7.65% from your nanny’s pay and pay a matching 7.65% yourself.
  • Unemployment taxes: federal unemployment tax kicks in if you pay $1,000 or more in any calendar quarter, plus your state’s unemployment tax.
  • Paperwork: you’ll need an employer ID number, a W-2 for your nanny each year, and Schedule H with your tax return.

Budget about 10% on top of wages for your share of taxes. A nanny payroll service can handle the filings for a monthly fee. Paying “under the table” can mean back taxes and penalties later, and leaves your nanny without unemployment or Social Security credit.

One parent stays home

The real cost is the paycheck you give up, after taxes, minus the work costs you’d stop paying (commuting, lunches, work clothes). If childcare would eat most of one parent’s take-home pay, staying home can make sense, at least for the first year or two.

Count the long-term costs too: lost retirement contributions and employer match, a gap on the resume, and raises that compound over a career. If you go this route, keep saving for retirement for the parent at home. A spousal IRA lets a working spouse contribute for a non-working one. And make sure the parent at home has life insurance too: their work would cost a lot to replace.

Tax breaks change the math

Paid childcare comes with two federal tax breaks, and they can’t cover the same dollars:

  • A dependent care FSA lets you pay up to $7,500 a year (2026) for childcare before taxes.
  • The child and dependent care credit is worth 20% to 50% of up to $3,000 in costs for one child or $6,000 for two or more.

For many families with a job-based FSA, the FSA saves more. Here’s the full breakdown: dependent care FSA vs. the childcare tax credit.

Your one next step

Get two or three real quotes this week, then plug them into the childcare cost calculator to see your true yearly cost for each option, after taxes.

This guide is for general education, not tax or legal advice. Household employer rules vary by state, so check your state’s requirements or talk to a tax professional.

Sources

Educational information only, not individual financial, tax or legal advice. Read our editorial standards.